Senior Claims Consultant

Open the door to your dream job and join #TeamMainStreet. With more than 40,000 homes in 30 markets, Main Street Renewal is one of the largest providers of single-family rental homes across the country. We understand that our employees are the invaluable drivers of our success. That's why we hire the most talented, passionate individuals who enjoy contributing to a growing, winning team. Here, you'll be a part of a fast-growing company dedicated to providing a best in class leasing and customer service experience to our residents.

Location: Austin, TX 

Preferred: Austin-area candidates able to work a hybrid schedule of 4 days in office, 1 remote day per week. 
Also considered: Highly qualified candidates outside the Austin area for a remote work arrangement. 

 
Position Summary 

The Senior Claims Consultant serves as a subject matter expert across property, catastrophe, general liability, auto, and workers' compensation claims. This role is responsible for managing complex claims, overseeing third-party administrators and vendors, evaluating coverage positions, and driving strategic initiatives that improve claims outcomes and operational efficiency. 

The ideal candidate possesses strong technical claims expertise, exceptional analytical and negotiation skills, and the ability to influence outcomes across internal and external stakeholders. This individual will play a key role in shaping the future of the Claims & Risk function through process improvement, operational excellence, and thought leadership. 

 
Key Responsibilities 
Claims Management & Oversight 

• Manage and oversee complex property, catastrophe, liability, auto, and workers' compensation claims. 

• Evaluate claim investigations, reserves, settlement recommendations, and coverage determinations. 

• Analyze claim documentation and supporting evidence to ensure appropriate claim outcomes. 

• Provide recommendations regarding claim strategy, coverage application, and settlement opportunities. 

• Maintain settlement authority up to assigned limits and provide recommendations on higher-exposure claims. 

Catastrophe & Property Claims 

• Lead the review and management of catastrophe and large-loss property claims. 

• Coordinate with carriers, TPAs, consultants, engineers, and forensic accounting firms. 

• Review business interruption analyses and property damage valuations. 

• Assist in claim preparation, documentation, and negotiation efforts. 

• Support disaster response activities and claim recovery initiatives.

​ 

TPA, Carrier & Vendor Management 

• Serve as a liaison with TPAs, carriers, brokers, attorneys, and external vendors. 

• Challenge claim decisions, reserve positions, and coverage interpretations when appropriate. 

• Monitor TPA performance and ensure adherence to service expectations. 

• Negotiate favorable claim outcomes on behalf of the organization.

​ 

Strategic Leadership & Subject Matter Expertise 

• Serve as a technical resource and trusted advisor for leadership and team members. 

• Communicate clear expectations on claims packages to internal field teams and external vendors. 

• Provide guidance and mentoring to less experienced claims professionals. 

• Identify emerging claim trends and recommend proactive risk mitigation strategies. 

• Participate in strategic planning discussions regarding claims management and risk financing. 

​

Process Improvement & Operational Excellence 

• Identify opportunities to improve claims processes, workflows, and reporting. 

• Assist in the development and implementation of claims KPIs and performance metrics. 

• Support technology initiatives and workflow optimization efforts in support of claims and policy management. 

• Contribute to the creation and maintenance of standard operating procedures and best practices. 

Qualifications 
Required 

• Bachelor's degree or equivalent combination of education and experience. 

• Minimum 8 years of progressive insurance claims experience. 

• Demonstrated experience handling complex property and casualty claims. 

• Strong understanding of insurance policy interpretation and coverage analysis. 

• Experience managing relationships with TPAs, carriers, brokers, and legal counsel. 

• Excellent negotiation, communication, and analytical skills. 

• Ability to manage multiple priorities in a fast-paced environment. 

​

Preferred 

• 10+ years of insurance claims experience. 

• Catastrophe and large-loss property claims experience. 

• Business interruption claims experience. 

• Experience within real estate, property management, multifamily, or large portfolio environments. 

• Self-insured retention program experience. 

• Texas All-Lines Adjuster License. 

• Professional designations such as AIC, CPCU, ARM, CIC, or SCLA. 

• Experience developing KPIs, dashboards, and process improvement initiatives. 

​

Success Measures 

• Improved claim outcomes and recoveries. 

• Effective management of catastrophe and large-loss claims. 

• Strong TPA performance. 

• Development of scalable claims processes and reporting. 

• Positive influence on team knowledge, efficiency, and strategic execution. 

​

Work Environment 

• Hybrid schedule: Four days in the Austin office and one remote workday per week. 

• Occasional travel (up to 15%) for claim reviews, inspections, meetings, or training. 

• Potential participation in significant catastrophe claim response activities. 

Amherst is proud to be an Equal Opportunity Employer and committed to creating an inclusive environment for all employees. We do not discriminate on the basis of race, color, religion, national origin, gender, pregnancy, sexual orientation, gender identity, age, physical or mental disability, genetic information or veteran status, and encourage all applicants to apply. 

Our full-time employee benefits include:

• A competitive compensation package, annual bonus, 401k match

• Flexible PTO including 7 paid holidays, 1 floating holiday, and 1 volunteer day

• Employer-paid benefits (medical, dental, vision, health savings account)

• Professional career development and reimbursement

• Up to 16 weeks paid maternity leave; up to 4 weeks of paid parental leave

• Backup childcare offered through Bright Horizons

​Main Street Renewal is proud to be an Equal Opportunity Employer and committed to creating an inclusive environment for all employees. We do not discriminate on the basis of race, color, religion, national origin, gender, pregnancy, sexual orientation, gender identity, age, physical or mental disability, genetic information or veteran status, and encourage all applicants to apply.